Different Sides of the Same Bench

I was early, as I usually am. First in, first out for any function.

I don’t mind waiting, whether it’s for work, a flight, or in this case, a play.

At least I won’t be stressed by running late, right?

I sat in the lobby waiting for my sister to arrive and was sharing a bench with another woman. As an easily clocked transwoman I know that it’s very likely someone will have a thought or an opinion about me.  I don’t care what they think of me, but I am aware that their thoughts MAY turn into actions, even if it’s unlikely.  It’s the potential action that I need to anticipate.

What I mean is that IF they do not care for non-binary people AND they want to share their worthless opinion with me, THEN I need to think about what I will do or how I will react.  Normally I would just leave the area if something like that happened, but we were in a theatre lobby and besides going to my car I didn’t have many options.

As far as I know, I cannot read minds.  I mean, I MIGHT be able to but maybe I just haven’t the proper training?  Since I (probably) lack this ability I don’t concern myself with what someone might think about me BUT I do look for, hm, clues? as to what they MAY do or say, IF they choose to interact with me at all.  For example, if they are with someone else I will, well, eavesdrop on whatever conservations they may have with each other.  If they start to make snide comments about me with the intention of me overhearing them then it’s safe to assume that they are not allies and I should probably sit somewhere else.

Of course, I don’t think I should have to move just because they have a problem with girls like me, I mean, that’s their problem, but I also know that I will be uncomfortable near them and I would prefer to not hear their opinions, especially if their intention is indeed for me to hear them.  I mean, YES, I could engage with them myself, but as I will explain in a moment, confrontation is not something I am comfortable with or even something I am good at. I have a short temper and tend to react badly and rashly when I am angry.

Moving is protecting my peace and my self-esteem I suppose.

If that person is alone, they may shoot angry looks at me or mutter something hateful under their breath with the intention of me hearing them.

Women (including transwomen and ciswomen) need to be aware of their surroundings and who they are near.  We are always on edge, unfortunately.

Despite having my guard up, I am thankful that the unpleasant experiences I have had while out en femme has been incredibly low relative to how often I am out.

Although my guard was up, I felt I was in an inclusive place.  I mean, I was at a theatre and if there’s a place that is more supportive of the queer community than a theatre I haven’t found it.

My bench companion was the first to break the silence.  She asked what play I was seeing and we started to chat.  She was friendly and didn’t seem fazed by me.  Again, I am easily clocked but if someone has any doubt about the gender I was assigned at birth, the doubt vanishes as soon as I speak.  I don’t have an especially deep voice but it’s not the light, soft voice that many people would describe as feminine.

As we conversed she disclosed that she herself used to work at this very theatre.  She shared some stories about her time there and I was eager to learn more about this history of the theatre.  She was now retired and asked what I did.  I never really know how to answer that question.  If you ask HIM what HE does, HE will say HE works in education.  But that’s HIS job, not Hannah’s.  Hannah doesn’t pull her weight lol.  And yes, I suppose I am overthinking such a mundane question but specifics matter.  After thinking about the question for a moment, I said that I am a writer.  If Hannah has a job then it’s writing this blog, writing reviews, and articles for The Breast Form Store.

She asked what I write about and I answered with what is probably an oversimplification.  I write mostly about gender.

And that’s when things turned in a direction I wasn’t expecting.  Up until now she was friendly and seemed to be an ally (I mean, if you hate people like me you PROBABLY won’t begin a conversation with someone like me) but she said something along the lines about gender identity getting out of hand.

I will be the first to admit that I have a hard time recalling conversations, especially when I have to relay them to someone (or blog about them).  I am an unreliable narrator and I admit it.  If I misrepresent something, or someone, it’s never intentional.  But since facts matter I will qualify this conversation in the best way that I can.  Any misrepresentation is not done so with malice, if you will.  On a similar note, if I read a novel and I like it, I will tell people I liked it, but if you ask me what the novel was about, I could not tell you.

After her comment I had no idea how to respond.  The entire vibe changed.  I didn’t know what she meant so I asked her to clarify.  I did this because I have a habit of misunderstanding something, reacting to that misunderstanding, and making things worse than they need to be.

From this point the conversation spiraled into so many opinions and perspectives that I struggled to follow along.  I suppose ‘conversation’ is too generous of a term as I felt I was at the receiving end of a long and wandering Facebook post written by someone who was misinformed about the realities of gender identity and gender affirming treatments thanks to the biased “reporting” of conservative media.

I was in over my head here which was frustrating and humbling because gender is one of my areas of expertise.  I realized I wasn’t having a dialogue with someone about gender and the exchange of ideas and opinions was not going to happen.  Sometimes people just talk to others with the goal of letting that person know their opinion with no intention of hearing someone else’s.  I felt I was, well, a bad t-girl, lol  I mean, this was an occasion where I had the opportunity to educate someone on the realities of gender identity and presentation but I was outmatched.

To clarify, I was outmatched in terms of conversation “style”.  When someone just…  talks and talks and says so many things I feel unable to respond because I feel I have to respond to every single thing that they said.  If you send me an email with five topics and questions, I will respond to each topic and question.  If we have a conversation in real life and you ask me about five different things, then I will want to respond to all five things.

When she did come up for breath and I had a chance to respond I didn’t even know where to start.  I was overwhelmed and frustrated.  So much of what she had to say was about kids and gender identity.  I had the impression that she really believed that schools did gender affirming surgery on kids, even against their will.  I had the impression that she felt that doctors just prescribe whatever a kid requested when it came to HRT.

When I gathered my thoughts I talked about the restrictions on gender affirming surgeries on people under the age of 18 and the realities about medical care when it comes to estrogen and puberty blockers and the like.  I don’t think she was listening.  The conversation shifted to “boys in the girls locker room” and parents screaming at teachers when it comes to demanding that they recognize their son is now their daughter.  She seemed to think that kids just “decide” that they are a different gender and then parents just pull a wig onto their son and ta-da, he’s a she.

She backtracked a little when she realized that I was silent once she stopped talking.  I was absorbing what she said and trying to decide how to respond and WHAT to respond to.  I think she wanted to show that she was an ally because her son was gay.  However she didn’t seem too excited about that.  She disclosed that she asked her son to not come out even though she was “fine” with him being gay.

I was reminded that gender identity is so commonly misunderstood and mischaracterized.  Just because someone is an ally of the queer community it doesn’t mean that they are not susceptible to fear-mongering.  I was naive enough to think, years ago, that all allies and all members of the queer community would be supportive, or at least not hateful, of the non-binary community.  Acceptance and tolerance should never be assumed, I suppose.

I didn’t feel composed enough to, well, debate her.  She seemed very, very confident in her beliefs and seemed sure about “what was really going on” and I have no interest in changing some people’s opinions and I didn’t have the wherewithal to even try.  She didn’t seem open to a different opinion.  Of course I could be very wrong and I am misrepresenting her, so I admit that.  I don’t think she hated transgender people but she seemed very upset about the idea of schools “transgendering” kids.  I told her that wasn’t happening but she doubled down.

Knowing I would be sharing a bench, or at least a lobby with her for the next thirty minutes or so, I changed the conversation completely.  I suppose I was retreating but these days I am coming to the realities of what is a foregone conclusion.

Soon we stopped talking altogether and the lobby started to fill with other theatre patrons, including her friend and my sister.

Acceptance and support can come from out of nowhere, the opposite is also true.  I said that acceptance should never be assumed but the opposite is also true.  The number of positive experiences just absolutely crush the negative ones.  Like, it’s not even close.

But if that ratio was flipped, it still wouldn’t be enough to keep me from being who I am.  Sure, it would be discouraging to say the least but living my life is more important than what someone else thinks about me.

Love, Hannah

Leave a Reply